| Game
Overview
The 2nd major expansion to
the original Carcassonne, Traders &
Builders aims to shake up the original play
just a little more than Inns & Cathedrals.
The term Traders in the title, weaves its
way into the game by introducing resources
to the world of Carcassonne. A total of
20 city tiles are offered and each of these
depicts a resource symbol - wine barrel,
grain or cloth. These are placed to create
cities just like any other tile but they
offer a special bonus. If any player (please
note the underline) can place the final
tile to complete a city containing resources,
they will earn a resource token to match
each of those resources. At the end of the
game a bonus 10 points is awarded to the
player that holds the most tokens of each
resource. That is a whopping 30 bonus points
that must be contested as the game progresses.
The obvious strategy dilemma here is that
players may feel compelled to complete an
opponent's city, earning them points, in
order to earn resource tokens and have a
shot at the bonus points. Diabolical!
The 2nd shake-up takes the form of the builder
and pig units. These both come in the form
of additional wooden pieces and are added
to your follower pool at the start of the
game. The builder is an extremely powerful
piece. It can be placed by a player whenever
they add a tile to a feature (city or road)
that they already control. If in future
turns they can add a tile to a feature that
contains their builder they will earn a
bonus turn, which is taken immediately.
This is huge as a player can effectively
increase the value of their city or road
and earn a bonus turn into the bargain.
Only one bonus turn can be taken each go.
If a feature is completed, the builder and
all followers are returned as per usual.
The pig is placed in a similar fashion to
the builder but this time it can be placed
on a farm region that the active player
already controls. It stays in play for the
entire game and if that farm region earns
points at the end of the game, it will earn
5 points per completed city instead of the
usual four.
This expansion also offers a bonus, this
time in the form of a cloth bag. This is
not only nice but almost essential as the
number of tiles used in the game (if both
expansions are used) is getting high.
|
| The
Final Word
In
terms of game changing mechanics, Traders
& Builders is the more dynamic of the
first 2 expansions. But like most things
it will come down to personal taste. This
is my favourite of all the expansions as
the thinking required is increased substantially.
However other players may feel they now
have too much to think about, especially
if they are also using Inns & Cathedrals
with this expansion. The only true way to
know is to play it for yourself and I highly
recommend that you do!
|